Najstnik se odloči, da bo poiskal svojega biološkega očeta.Jules in Nic Allgood sta lezbični par v dolgoletnem, predanem in ljubečem razmerju, ki pa ni popolno. Nic, po poklicu zdravnica, želi imeti vse pod nadzorom, medtem ko je Jules, ki poskuša uspeti z lastnim podjetjem za urejanje okolice, precej bolj sproščena in nesamozavestna. Jules in Nic sta tudi materi dvema najstniškima otrokoma, spočetima z umetno oploditvijo: Jules je biološka mati 18-letne Joni, Nic pa 15-letnega Laserja, medtem ko je njun skupni oče neznan darovalec sperme. Preden odide Joni študirat, jo mlajši brat prosi, naj skrivaj vzpostavi stik s semensko banko in izve identiteto njunega biološkega očeta. Ko skrivnost pride na dan in očeta Paula predstavita družini, se dokaj umirjeno družinsko življenje zaplete.
Nic and Jules are in a long term, committed, loving but by no means perfect same-sex relationship. Nic, a physician, needs to wield what she believes is control, whereas Jules, under that control, is less self-assured. During their relationship, Jules has floundered in her "nine to five" life, sometimes trying to start a business - always unsuccessfully - or being the stay-at-home mom. She is currently trying to start a landscape design business. They have two teen-aged children, Joni (conceived by Nic) and Laser (by Jules). Although not exact replicas, each offspring does more closely resemble his/her biological mother in temperament. Joni and Laser are also half-siblings, having the same unknown sperm donor father. Shortly after Joni's eighteenth birthday and shortly before she plans to leave the house and head off to college, Laser, only fifteen and underage to do so, pleads with her to try and contact their sperm donor father. Somewhat reluctantly, she does. He is late thirty-something Paul, a co-op farmer and restaurateur. Despite his seemingly successful businesses, Paul has always shirked responsibility, most specifically in his personal life. After Joni and Laser meet with Paul, Nic and Jules learn what their children have done and, although they don't want Paul infiltrating their lives, want to meet him - especially as Joni and Laser seem to want to maintain some sort of relationship with him. As Paul's relationship with the entire family grows (which includes his hiring Jules to design and construct his backyard), they have an effect on what he wants in life. In turn, he affects their family dynamic as well as each person's relationships outside of it.